Show up online: social media and digital strategy for co-ops

| Mentorship Hour

Dawn Walker (CoSocial) generously shared her expertise on social media and digital strategy for co-operatives, and we left with plenty to think about. Here are a few of the takeaways that stood out:

1. Search engine traffic is shrinking (rapidly), and word of mouth is holding up.

Websites report traffic from Google down 21.9% in 2024-25 and 40.2% in 2025-26, driven largely by AI overviews. Loyal audiences, especially ones arriving via newsletters, stay stable, and “direct” and “dark social” traffic (links shared in texts and DMs) is growing. Direct channels like email, phone, DMs, pop-ups and events matter more again.

2. The linear marketing funnel is giving way to “influence maps”.

We covered four online behaviours: streaming, scrolling, searching and shopping. Customers hit many touchpoints repeatedly, so channels should be treated as a web of touchpoints, not one traditional “marketing funnel”.

3. Authenticity is the co-op advantage.

With AI-generated content everywhere, human storytelling and a consistent voice rooted in co-op values helps you stand out.

4. Open social media is growing, and some of it is co-op run.

  • Bluesky and the Atmosphere networks have about 40 million users.
  • Mastodon and the Fediverse have about 12 million users.
  • Co-op providers include CoSocial, Social.coop, Northsky Social and Inference Cooperative.
  • Most organizations that experiment add a channel rather than leaving their existing ones.

5. Next steps depend on where you are.
A readiness check-in sorts you as just starting, mid-way, or already strategic.

Suggested steps are:

  • Audit your communication tools
  • Try an alternative platform
  • Sketch influence maps
  • Look at data sovereignty and resilience.

Learn more about Dawn’s work at CoSocial.